The Rules: arguing after a traffic accident

By ~
| Being Chinese about it | Culture stress |

His language teachers later told him that he should have stayed lying on the road until a crowd formed. Then get up, blame the driver, and make demands. With a crowd around him, the children, and the driver, all passing judgment against the driver, she would be forced to negotiate and eventually pay something. That’s not what happened this time, and I thought it was interesting how it played out.

We haven’t had a traffic accident yet, but one of the German doctors who ate the frogs with us did last week. Interesting story from a cultural perspective.

sanlunchesmall.JPGHe was driving an electric three-wheel cart (sān lún chē – 三轮车) with kindergarten aged kids in the back. A car trying to squeeze through a red light ahead of the vehicles turning left almost plowed into the sān lún chē. They both hit the brakes and he swerved so hard he fell off onto the road. Thankfully, the sān lún chē was designed for the cart to stay level even if the driver tipped over. He was scratched and shaken up a bit, angry and scared, but not really hurt. The kids were OK. The car stopped about half a meter away from them. And here’s where the rules come in.

Usually if there’s an accident the bigger vehicle is at fault, or at least partially at fault. Plus, this driver was clearly in the wrong by running the red light and driving out of her lane. But instead of lying in the road while a crowd formed, our friend got up off the road right away, slammed on the hood of the car and started trying to argue with the driver through the driver-side window. And that was her chance. She put both hands on the steering wheel and stared straight ahead, refusing to acknowledge that he was even there. It was infuriating, but with no crowd gathering around a victim in the road, she wasn’t forced to negotiate. Eventually he was forced to give up and they went their separate ways. But not before he loudly told her something like, “You have no courtesy,” and a taxi driver across the street laughed and gave him the thumbs up sign.

The driver’s reaction reminds me of the two girls we saw getting yelled at on Saturday; they just sat there as if the irate boyfriend/husband wasn’t there. I don’t know what all is going on with all this, but one day hopefully we will.

Share

6 replies to “The Rules: arguing after a traffic accident”


  1. oh, it gets better. I’m reading stuff on face practices right now, and I suppose one day it will all make sense, but the case studies are fascinating… different “cultural grammars” as some of these authors say. People are more different on the inside than our mushy multicultural overlords realize, i think.

    It’s like the few times we’ve watched made-for-Chinese Chinese movies, and have no clue why people got mad, sad, happy, or suicidal, or why they would respond in certain ways.


  2. howdy joel and jessica. this is sharon..josh temple and billy’s mom. thought i would put my 2 bits in about this emotion reaction deal. did you ever see the movie “Good Morning Vietnam”? there is a scene when robin williams is teaching the class and teaching them how to verbally react to different situations. anyway, he talks to one and the guy says “i do nothing” which makes robin very irritated. and then he tells the man what someone is doing to him and the man says “i do nothing..i just remain reticent”. i think that by doing nothing and giving no credit to the angry person..the passive person is gaining the power of the situation. it is nothing to have someone react to you..but to not react..you are getting the upper hand and so the power is in your court..and the angry person has lost all power in the situation. it is all about control. why feed on someone’s anger and give them the satisfaction of feeding that anger? when it is sooo very much sweeter to do nothing and letting them lose control? anyway, that is my thoughts on it. also, i’ve very much enjoyed the daily emails. tell jessica i miss her coffee muffins. oh yeah, we all got together yesterday at nelson’s house. and we were wondering if we wanted to send you something..say a birthday present..how would we go about doing that? what is the proper procedure for doing that?
    we miss you…our thoughts are always with you..and i can’t wait to hear from you.
    sharon


  3. Hey Sharon, good to hear from you! The stuff you described from that movie sounds like the kinds of passive-aggressive power games they told us to avoid when we had our premarital counseling. I miss Jessica’s coffee muffins, too. We don’t have an oven over here. If you e-mail us we can send you mailing info. So nice to be remembered! =) Say hi to the Patriarch and the kids for us.


  4. Rice cookers! That’s how we cook, and we have a stove top. Man, little Josh isn’t little anymore? And driving? Crazy! Say hi to both of them for us, and it’d be cool to get an e-mail from those guys.

Leave a Reply...

Subscribe




About

A North American couple with a background in Intercultural Studies tries to make a life in China. This is our coping mechanismblog.

Share on Facebook

We both write, but Jessica only writes when I bribe her. See all of her posts here.

Subscribe/Follow

Enter your email address:

Subscribe

Add to Google

Choose a Topic

  • Baijiu (白酒) (6)
  • Beauty (10)
  • Being Chinese about it (143)
  • Blessings (68)
  • China books & DVDs (48)
  • China plans & prep (11)
  • China web debris (445)
  • China: life & times (264)
  • ChinaHopeLive.net (13)
  • Chinese festivals (44)
  • Chinese history (29)
  • Chinese medicine (15)
  • Chinese movies (6)
  • Chinese songs (10)
  • Chinese take-out (215)
  • Chinglish (22)
  • Christmas (22)
  • Cultural perspectives (149)
  • Cultural re-adjustment (7)
  • Culture fun (142)
  • Culture stress (50)
  • Cute (33)
  • Face (14)
  • Family (60)
  • Friends Far Away (7)
  • Goodbyes (6)
  • How to… (13)
  • Karaoke (7)
  • Learning (55)
  • Learning Mandarin (96)
  • Lost in translation (24)
  • Love (18)
  • M.A. studies (23)
  • Marriage (28)
  • Meta-narratives (78)
  • oh. Canada (6)
  • Olympics (31)
  • People (130)
  • Photo posts (128)
  • Places (242)
  • Pollution (21)
  • Propaganda (70)
  • Random (3)
  • Running wild in the streets (116)
  • Sex & Sexuality (17)
  • Soapboxes (35)
  • Teaching English (56)
  • Things we've eaten (54)
  • Traffic (12)
  • Travelling (30)
  • Underappreciated genius (14)
  • Translate 翻译

    Latest Posts

  • Asian ‘gendercide’ in Canada — our local paper opens an explosive can of worms

  • Fair Trade iPhones

  • Eaves-dropping on Beijingers in Vancouver

  • Chinese “evil cult” propaganda in our Canadian mailbox

  • Japanese apologies

  • Merry Christmas 2011! (“Is there anything worth believing in?”)

  • The ChinaHopeLive.net 2011 China photo gallery is up!

  • How we participated in China’s rampant residential electricity thieving

  • China’s “leftover women” [Updated]

  • Morality, ‘Face’ and China’s religious market

  • China’s sexual education, taboos and consequences

  • Cross-cultural living and the desire to be intimately known

  • Lest we forget

  • Factory Girls, communal village life, and the growth of individualism in China

  • Lying, “Lying” and Mainland China [Updated 2x]

  • Racism in Vancouver, Canada and my ESL student’s experience

  • Scene clips & screen stills from “1911″ (we were extras!)

  • “Mao’s Great Famine” and China’s moral landscape

  • Prostitution in Tianjin, China — anecdotes, STD vocab, and how one group of local women is fighting back

  • The suspiciously Orwellian children’s story 《鸭子农夫》 “Farmer Duck” Chinese-Pinyin-English read-along


  • Photos

    smallsquare3fireworks1.JPG smallsquare2bug1.JPG smallsquare1pagoda1.JPG smallsquare5lu1.JPG

    Browse our photos here!

    Conversations

    Fair Trade iPhones (2)
     baroness radon: "I remember a Starbucks cup from several years..."
     Lorin Yochim: "“Saving the world…one cup at a..."

    China’s ‘century of humiliation’ and the Olympics (1)
     Afi: "The most irmpotant reason why China may not invest in the..."

    Foreign baby in China essentials: IMPORTED BABY FORMULA (24)
     damien: "I am going to have a baby in china , are there USA..."

    Steve Jobs, Apple, China and Us [updated] (16)
     Dr Ross Grainger: "The American CEOs I mentioned are less..."
     Max: "I understand that, but look what Erica wrote: “paying too..."

    Affordable gadgets vs. Chinese workers’ rights (2)
     Joel 大江: "Do you know what got him interested in Chinese..."
     Meredith: "Mike Daisey, who is featured in the CBS News article..."

    Happy Lantern Festival 2011 from Tianjin, China! (7)
     Joel 大江: "Hi Rachel! These photos and video were taken on the..."
     Rachel Harwood: "We are expats in Teda, and this is our first..."

    Videos

    chlvideo.png

    See the videos page!

    Chinese take-out

    Good good study, day day up!

    国保/国宝

    Pronounced: guó ​bǎo
    Literally: National Security/National Treasure
    Means: The two terms are homophones, and "national treasure" often means "panda". A writer at Seeing Red in China explains the rest: "how panda becomes the symbol for Chinese security thugs: Chinese national security (more like secret police) is called 国保 (guó ​bǎo) for short, and it’s pronounced exactly the same as 国宝, national treasure. Netizens sometimes refer 国保 as 国宝, jokingly, hence Panda, China’s national treasure. Kungfu Panda movies provided the basis for Panda to be a martial character."

    With the recent confrontation between Batman actor Christian Bale and some infamous Chinese security thugs, online Chinese are been passing around "Pandaman vs. Batman" jokes, and photoshopping "Pandaman" into all kinds of scenarios, including movie posters and images from other security embarrassments and scandals. See here, here and here for more.

    - 2011/12/19

    View all

    InterWǎng Debris

    Recent China internet debris.

    Affordable gadgets vs. Chinese workers' rights

    Three recent news articles (and one response) return the spotlight to the mammoth electronics factories in China that make most of our favourite electronics, pointing out what everybody knows and no one wants to think about:

    Happy Chinese workers spell the end of affordable tech (ZDNet)
    "Human and worker rights reforms in China would have serious negative consequences for the efficiency and cost of the gadget supply chain.
    [...]
    "Foxconn’s client list reads like a celebrity tech roster that includes Hewlett-Packard, Dell, Intel, Lenovo, IBM, Cisco/Linksys, Netgear, Microsoft, Sharp, Sony, Motorola, Asus, Acer and Vizio... tablet runners and e-reader champions Amazon and Barnes & Noble. Yes, your Kindles and Nooks are also made by the very same companies with the same awful working conditions that make products for Apple."

    The dark side of shiny Apple products (CBS News)
    "...our most popular electronic devices are largely made by hand ... MANY hands, as it turns out ... hands that often are very over-worked, or so industry's critics contend."
    [...]
    ""I met workers who were 12. Do you really think Apple doesn't know?"

    "But what was news were the suicides..."

    In China, Human Costs Are Built Into an iPad (NYT)
    and
    BSR: New York Times’ Apple-Foxconn article contains untruths, inaccuracies, and misleading info (Mac Daily News)

    - 2012/02/06

    Those aren't Chinese New Year's fireworks; they're "recreational munitions"

    From Nankai Rob's Chinese New Year 2012 post "Spring Festival Time. . .Lock and Load":
    "...parties are held on a scale so massive that Caligula would have nodded in approval, and enough recreational munitions are set off to make the Battle of Waterloo feel like a suburban bar mitzvah. You’ll notice my careful word choice here: “recreational munitions” rather than “fireworks.” “Fireworks” as a term carries with it more celebratory, even innocent connotations, but you can’t define Chinese celebratory fireworks by the intent behind them. Certainly they’re set off with great excitement and joy, but you can, after all, also lob a grenade into a dumpster with great excitement and joy, and most of what is being set off these days qualifies for inclusion in the dumpster-grenade category. So: recreational munitions."

    For more about the genuinely stunning Chinese New Year fireworks phenomenon with photos and video, see:

    Happy Chinese New Year!

    - 2012/01/22

    Tension rising with Mainland students in American universities

    Interesting observations at China Law Blog about how Mainland Chinese students studying in the USA -- in contrast to Chinese from other countries -- are apparently generating a lot of anger among the American students: Chinese Students In America. It's Bad Out There.

    It seems that Mainland Chinese attitudes toward education don't play well among their American classmates. For example:

    "They cheat all the time. It is pretty unbelievable how often I have seen them cheating. I am always complaining to my professors about this, but they usually just act like they are too important to deign to deal with something like this. Just come watch a test being adminstered and it will be obvious. They are allowed to get away with it because they pay the foreign tuition rate."

    "One student told me of how all the students not from China agreed not to speak one day to see what would happen. There was no class discussion and the teacher asked them not to do it again."

    - 2012/01/11

    View all

    What's this?

    Links

    Learning Chinese
    Learning China
    Friends
    Other Stuff


      RSS
      ~
      LEGAL:
    All text, images, and photographs are the sole property of the authors unless otherwise indicated.
    Copyright (c) 2005-2011 ChinaHopeLive. All rights reserved. Contact Joel and Jessica for copyright details.
      ~
      Increase your website traffic with Attracta.com
      ~


    Best Blogs Asia Directory Featured in Alltop living in China News blogs & blog posts

    Switch to our mobile site