Logic vs Intuition, Round 2

By ~
| Being Chinese about it | China books & DVDs | Chinese medicine | Cultural perspectives | My Country & My People |

In My Country and My People, 林语堂 (Lín Yǔtáng) contrasts Chinese and Western thinking this way: Westerners are more inclined to logic, reason, the scientific method, and analysis; the Chinese are more inclined to intuition, reasonableness, and common sense. Here he gives a historical example of what happens when you apply an intuitive approach to, say, human biology and comparative religion.

…the logic of common sense can only be applied to human affairs and actions; it cannot be applied to the solution of the riddles of the universe. One can use reasonableness to settle a dispute but not to locate the relative positions of the heart and liver or determine the function of the pancreatic juice. Hence in divining nature’s mysteries and the secrets of the human body, the Chinese have to resort largely to intuition. Strangely enough they have intuitively felt the heart to be on the right and the liver to be on the left side of the human chest. An erudite Chinese scholar, whose voluminous Notebooks are widely read, came across a copy of Human Anatomy translated by the Jesuits Jacobus Rho, James Terrence, and Nicolaus Longobardi, and finding that in the book the heart is placed on the left and the liver on the right, decided that Westerners have different internal organs from the Chinese, and deduced therefrom the important conclusion that since their internal organs are different, therefore their religion must also be different — this deduction is in itself a perfect example of intuitive reasoning — and hence only Chinese whose internal organs are imperfect could possibly become Christian converts. The erudite scholar slyly remarked that if the Jesuits only knew this fact they would not be interested in preaching Christianity in China and in making converts of half-normal beings.

Such assertions are made in perfect seriousness and in fact are typical of Chinese “intuition” in the realms of natural science and human physiology. One begins to believe there is something after all in the scientific method … He could have at least felt the palpitation of his heart by his own hand, but evidently the Chinese scholar never descended to manual labour.

Thus free from the stupid drudgery in the use of his eye and his hands, and having a naive faith in the power of his “intuition,” the Chinese scholar goes about explaining the mysteries of the human body and the universe to his own satisfaction.

[from pages 90-91 in my 2002 edition.]

Related Articles:

Share

6 replies to “Logic vs Intuition, Round 2”


  1. ha, maybe we should have a sense of impending doom or something, like every step we gain in the language is one step closer to banging my head against a very large, very hard wall of cultural differences. but, you know, Intercultural Studies degrees… supposedly we’re prepared for this ;)

    this kind of stuff often reminds me of the Babelfish in Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy – the little fish you put in your ear that lets you instantly and perfectly understand what people from other cultures are really saying. They credit the Babelfish for causing more wars than any other single thing in the universe. “If we really understood each other…?”


  2. If you’re interested, Joel, three years ago I wrote a small booklet regarding My Country and My People, and published it on my blog.

    That book has got to be one of the best “life-changing” books I have ever read, especially when it comes to understanding this country.


  3. Thanks Ben. I’ll get after that once I finish the book. While there’s plenty in it to quibble with, of everything I’ve read so far I have the least hesitations putting this one on a “required reading” list for foreigners coming to China. It has the right combination or readability, length, perspective, and sassyness to make an enjoyable and informative read, and you don’t need a masters degree to access it.

Leave a Reply...

Subscribe




About

A North American couple with a background in Intercultural Studies tries to make a life in China. This is our coping mechanismblog.

Share on Facebook

We both write, but Jessica only writes when I bribe her. See all of her posts here.

Subscribe/Follow

Enter your email address:

Subscribe

Add to Google

Choose a Topic

  • Baijiu (白酒) (6)
  • Beauty (10)
  • Being Chinese about it (143)
  • Blessings (68)
  • China books & DVDs (48)
  • China plans & prep (11)
  • China web debris (445)
  • China: life & times (264)
  • ChinaHopeLive.net (13)
  • Chinese festivals (44)
  • Chinese history (29)
  • Chinese medicine (15)
  • Chinese movies (6)
  • Chinese songs (10)
  • Chinese take-out (215)
  • Chinglish (22)
  • Christmas (22)
  • Cultural perspectives (149)
  • Cultural re-adjustment (7)
  • Culture fun (142)
  • Culture stress (50)
  • Cute (33)
  • Face (14)
  • Family (60)
  • Friends Far Away (7)
  • Goodbyes (6)
  • How to… (13)
  • Karaoke (7)
  • Learning (55)
  • Learning Mandarin (96)
  • Lost in translation (24)
  • Love (18)
  • M.A. studies (23)
  • Marriage (28)
  • Meta-narratives (78)
  • oh. Canada (6)
  • Olympics (31)
  • People (130)
  • Photo posts (128)
  • Places (242)
  • Pollution (21)
  • Propaganda (70)
  • Random (3)
  • Running wild in the streets (116)
  • Sex & Sexuality (17)
  • Soapboxes (35)
  • Teaching English (56)
  • Things we've eaten (54)
  • Traffic (12)
  • Travelling (30)
  • Underappreciated genius (14)
  • Translate 翻译

    Latest Posts

  • Asian ‘gendercide’ in Canada — our local paper opens an explosive can of worms

  • Fair Trade iPhones

  • Eaves-dropping on Beijingers in Vancouver

  • Chinese “evil cult” propaganda in our Canadian mailbox

  • Japanese apologies

  • Merry Christmas 2011! (“Is there anything worth believing in?”)

  • The ChinaHopeLive.net 2011 China photo gallery is up!

  • How we participated in China’s rampant residential electricity thieving

  • China’s “leftover women” [Updated]

  • Morality, ‘Face’ and China’s religious market

  • China’s sexual education, taboos and consequences

  • Cross-cultural living and the desire to be intimately known

  • Lest we forget

  • Factory Girls, communal village life, and the growth of individualism in China

  • Lying, “Lying” and Mainland China [Updated 2x]

  • Racism in Vancouver, Canada and my ESL student’s experience

  • Scene clips & screen stills from “1911″ (we were extras!)

  • “Mao’s Great Famine” and China’s moral landscape

  • Prostitution in Tianjin, China — anecdotes, STD vocab, and how one group of local women is fighting back

  • The suspiciously Orwellian children’s story 《鸭子农夫》 “Farmer Duck” Chinese-Pinyin-English read-along


  • Photos

    smallsquare3fireworks1.JPG smallsquare2bug1.JPG smallsquare1pagoda1.JPG smallsquare5lu1.JPG

    Browse our photos here!

    Conversations

    Fair Trade iPhones (2)
     baroness radon: "I remember a Starbucks cup from several years..."
     Lorin Yochim: "“Saving the world…one cup at a..."

    China’s ‘century of humiliation’ and the Olympics (1)
     Afi: "The most irmpotant reason why China may not invest in the..."

    Foreign baby in China essentials: IMPORTED BABY FORMULA (24)
     damien: "I am going to have a baby in china , are there USA..."

    Steve Jobs, Apple, China and Us [updated] (16)
     Dr Ross Grainger: "The American CEOs I mentioned are less..."
     Max: "I understand that, but look what Erica wrote: “paying too..."

    Affordable gadgets vs. Chinese workers’ rights (2)
     Joel 大江: "Do you know what got him interested in Chinese..."
     Meredith: "Mike Daisey, who is featured in the CBS News article..."

    Happy Lantern Festival 2011 from Tianjin, China! (7)
     Joel 大江: "Hi Rachel! These photos and video were taken on the..."
     Rachel Harwood: "We are expats in Teda, and this is our first..."

    Videos

    chlvideo.png

    See the videos page!

    Chinese take-out

    Good good study, day day up!

    国保/国宝

    Pronounced: guó ​bǎo
    Literally: National Security/National Treasure
    Means: The two terms are homophones, and "national treasure" often means "panda". A writer at Seeing Red in China explains the rest: "how panda becomes the symbol for Chinese security thugs: Chinese national security (more like secret police) is called 国保 (guó ​bǎo) for short, and it’s pronounced exactly the same as 国宝, national treasure. Netizens sometimes refer 国保 as 国宝, jokingly, hence Panda, China’s national treasure. Kungfu Panda movies provided the basis for Panda to be a martial character."

    With the recent confrontation between Batman actor Christian Bale and some infamous Chinese security thugs, online Chinese are been passing around "Pandaman vs. Batman" jokes, and photoshopping "Pandaman" into all kinds of scenarios, including movie posters and images from other security embarrassments and scandals. See here, here and here for more.

    - 2011/12/19

    View all

    InterWǎng Debris

    Recent China internet debris.

    Affordable gadgets vs. Chinese workers' rights

    Three recent news articles (and one response) return the spotlight to the mammoth electronics factories in China that make most of our favourite electronics, pointing out what everybody knows and no one wants to think about:

    Happy Chinese workers spell the end of affordable tech (ZDNet)
    "Human and worker rights reforms in China would have serious negative consequences for the efficiency and cost of the gadget supply chain.
    [...]
    "Foxconn’s client list reads like a celebrity tech roster that includes Hewlett-Packard, Dell, Intel, Lenovo, IBM, Cisco/Linksys, Netgear, Microsoft, Sharp, Sony, Motorola, Asus, Acer and Vizio... tablet runners and e-reader champions Amazon and Barnes & Noble. Yes, your Kindles and Nooks are also made by the very same companies with the same awful working conditions that make products for Apple."

    The dark side of shiny Apple products (CBS News)
    "...our most popular electronic devices are largely made by hand ... MANY hands, as it turns out ... hands that often are very over-worked, or so industry's critics contend."
    [...]
    ""I met workers who were 12. Do you really think Apple doesn't know?"

    "But what was news were the suicides..."

    In China, Human Costs Are Built Into an iPad (NYT)
    and
    BSR: New York Times’ Apple-Foxconn article contains untruths, inaccuracies, and misleading info (Mac Daily News)

    - 2012/02/06

    Those aren't Chinese New Year's fireworks; they're "recreational munitions"

    From Nankai Rob's Chinese New Year 2012 post "Spring Festival Time. . .Lock and Load":
    "...parties are held on a scale so massive that Caligula would have nodded in approval, and enough recreational munitions are set off to make the Battle of Waterloo feel like a suburban bar mitzvah. You’ll notice my careful word choice here: “recreational munitions” rather than “fireworks.” “Fireworks” as a term carries with it more celebratory, even innocent connotations, but you can’t define Chinese celebratory fireworks by the intent behind them. Certainly they’re set off with great excitement and joy, but you can, after all, also lob a grenade into a dumpster with great excitement and joy, and most of what is being set off these days qualifies for inclusion in the dumpster-grenade category. So: recreational munitions."

    For more about the genuinely stunning Chinese New Year fireworks phenomenon with photos and video, see:

    Happy Chinese New Year!

    - 2012/01/22

    Tension rising with Mainland students in American universities

    Interesting observations at China Law Blog about how Mainland Chinese students studying in the USA -- in contrast to Chinese from other countries -- are apparently generating a lot of anger among the American students: Chinese Students In America. It's Bad Out There.

    It seems that Mainland Chinese attitudes toward education don't play well among their American classmates. For example:

    "They cheat all the time. It is pretty unbelievable how often I have seen them cheating. I am always complaining to my professors about this, but they usually just act like they are too important to deign to deal with something like this. Just come watch a test being adminstered and it will be obvious. They are allowed to get away with it because they pay the foreign tuition rate."

    "One student told me of how all the students not from China agreed not to speak one day to see what would happen. There was no class discussion and the teacher asked them not to do it again."

    - 2012/01/11

    View all

    What's this?

    Links

    Learning Chinese
    Learning China
    Friends
    Other Stuff


      RSS
      ~
      LEGAL:
    All text, images, and photographs are the sole property of the authors unless otherwise indicated.
    Copyright (c) 2005-2011 ChinaHopeLive. All rights reserved. Contact Joel and Jessica for copyright details.
      ~
      Increase your website traffic with Attracta.com
      ~


    Best Blogs Asia Directory Featured in Alltop living in China News blogs & blog posts

    Switch to our mobile site